What Is The Best Dress Shoe Color For Men?

Choosing the best dress shoe color and style is significant for any professional man. Should you wear dark brown shoes? Or, are black color shoes the best? The choice between black shoes and brown shoes can influence your overall style and versatility. This guide will help you understand the differences and make an informed decision. We will also discuss some shoe styles, such as Oxford or cap-toe versus loafers.

Understanding the Basics

Black Dress Shoes

Black shoes are considered formal shoes. They are the traditional choice for formal events and are often required in conservative professional settings. Black shoes pair seamlessly with black and gray suits, making them a staple for formal occasions. Most men go with black for their first pair of dress shoes. I recommend a basic Oxford in a more formal office setting.  For more business casual, go with a black loafer.  Pictured are examples of each from my collection.

From left to right: Carlos Santos Derbies, To Boot NY Loafers, To Boot NY Loafers, To Boot NY Cap Toe Oxford

Brown Dress Shoes

Brown shoes offer versatility and a touch of personality. They come in various shades, from light tan to dark chocolate, allowing for flexibility in styling. Brown shoes pair well with blue and brown suits, making them suitable for formal and semi-formal events. Allen Edmonds offers Chili and Dark Chili shoes.  These are in the “brown” category, along with “Cognac” patina dress shoes. Cognac is an attractive color and considered a lighter shade of brown.

From Left to Right: TLB Mallorca Artista, Loake Buckingham, Amberjack The Cap Toe, Alden Bal Oxfords, Allen Edmonds Chilli Park Avenues

Matching Shoes with Suits

Gray Suit

Gray Slacks Brown Wingtip Shoes

Gray suits are neutral and can be paired with black and brown shoes. Black shoes are the best choice for a more formal look, while brown shoes can add warmth and contrast for a more relaxed appearance. This one is “dealer’s choice.” Many argue that navy blue suits are the most versatile, but it might be gray. For dress shirts and shoes, gray can go with anything.

Blue Suit

Black Loafers with Navy Pants

Blue suits, especially navy, pair exceptionally well with brown shoes. However, dark navy or midnight blue suits pair well with black shoes. The combination offers a modern and stylish look suitable for various occasions. Black shoes can be worn with dark blue suits. They create a more formal and traditional appearance.

Brown Suit

Brown suits naturally match brown shoes. The monochromatic look is cohesive and stylish. Black shoes are not recommended with brown suits. They clash with the warm tones.

Black Suit

Black suits are best paired with black shoes. This combination maintains the formal integrity of the outfit. However, you do not see black suits in today’s business world.  Black is too formal. If you have to wear black, never wear brown shoes. They disrupt the uniformity and formality.

Considering the Occasion

Formal Events

Black Oxford Dress Shoes

Black shoes are the standard for formal events such as weddings, funerals, or black-tie affairs. They convey a sense of tradition and seriousness appropriate for such occasions.

Job Interviews

In job interviews, especially in conservative industries, black shoes are often safer. They present a polished and professional image. However, brown shoes can showcase individuality in creative fields while maintaining a professional look.

Exploring Different Styles

Oxford Shoes

Oxford shoes are the most formal style of dress shoes. They feature a closed lacing system, giving them a sleek appearance. Both black and brown Oxford shoes are essential in a well-rounded wardrobe.(Real Men Real Style). There is nothing like a classic pair of plack Oxfords, especially with a Cap Toe.  If you are undecided about your first dress shoe, you cannot go wrong with a pair of black Oxford dress shoes.

Oxford vs. Derby Shoes

Derbies

Derby Shoes or “Derbies” are a less formal than Oxford dress shoes.  The key difference is the lacing system. Oxfords have a “closed” lacing system, whereas Derbies are open. See the photo for a visual understanding.

Monk Straps

Florsheim Sorrento Monk Straps

Monk strap shoes, characterized by their buckle closures, offer a stylish alternative to traditional lace-ups. They are versatile and can be worn in both formal and casual settings. Brown monk straps are particularly popular for their unique look.

Loafers

Brown Horsebit Loafers

Loafer colors should be black, brown or sometimes burgundy. Black loafers are a great first choice that provide comfort and ease. They are suitable for less formal occasions and can be dressed up or down depending on the outfit.(GQ)

Making the Best Choice

When selecting your first pair of dress shoes, consider the following:

• Versatility: Brown shoes offer more versatility in casual and semi-formal settings.
• Formality: Black shoes are essential for formal events and conservative workplaces.
• Personal Style: Choose a color that aligns with your personal style and the suits you own.
• Investment: Opt for high-quality brown leather shoes or black leather shoes that will last and age well.

Conclusion

In conclusion, black and brown shoes have their place in a young man’s wardrobe. If you attend many formal events or work in a conservative environment, black Oxford shoes are a must-have. For more versatility and a touch of personality, brown dress shoes, such as monk straps or loafers, are excellent choices. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your lifestyle, wardrobe, and personal preferences. Looking to find the right sport coat or blazer? Read Gray vs. Navy Sport Coats.

For a visual guide on choosing between black and brown shoes, check out the following video:

Black Vs Brown Shoes: How To Choose